Cost‐effectiveness analysis of a multicentre randomized clinical trial comparing surgery with conservative management for recurrent and ongoing diverticulitis (DIRECT trial). BJS 2019; 106: 448-457.
Published: 19th December 2018
Authors: H. E. Bolkenstein, G. A. de Wit, E. C. J. Consten, B. J. M. Van de Wall, I. A. M. J. Broeders, W. A. Draaisma et al.
The results of the DIRECT trial, an RCT comparing conservative management with elective sigmoid resection in patients with recurrent diverticulitis or persistent complaints, showed that elective sigmoid resection leads to higher quality of life. The aim of this study is to determine the cost‐effectiveness of surgical treatment at 1‐ and 5‐year follow‐up from a societal perspective.
Clinical effectiveness and resource use were derived from the DIRECT trial. The actual resource use and quality of life (EQ‐5D‐3L™ score) were documented prospectively per individual patient and analysed according to the intention‐to‐treat principle for up to 5 years after randomization. The main outcome was the incremental cost‐effectiveness ratio (ICER), expressed as costs per quality‐adjusted life‐year (QALY).
The study included 106 patients, of whom 50 were randomized to surgery and 56 to conservative treatment. At 1‐ and 5‐year follow‐up an incremental effect (QALY difference between groups) of 0·06 and 0·43 respectively was found, and an incremental cost (cost difference between groups) of €6957 and €2674 respectively, where surgery was more expensive than conservative treatment. This resulted in an ICER of €123 365 per additional QALY at 1‐year follow‐up, and €6275 at 5 years. At a threshold of €20 000 per QALY, operative treatment has 0 per cent probability of being cost‐effective at 1‐year follow‐up, but a 95 per cent probability at 5 years.
At 5‐year follow‐up, elective sigmoid resection in patients with recurring diverticulitis or persistent complaints was found to be cost‐effective. Registration number: NTR1478 (
You may also be interested in
Authors: R. L. Venchiarutti, M. J. Solomon, C. E. Koh, J. M. Young, D. Steffens
Meta‐analysis of randomized clinical trials of early versus delayed cholecystectomy for mild gallstone pancreatitis.
Authors: N. Moody, A. Adiamah, F. Yanni, D. Gomez
Meta‐analysis of the role of colonoscopy after an episode of left‐sided acute diverticulitis. BJS 2019; 106: 988-997.
Authors: S. J. Rottier, S. T. Dijk, A. A. W. Geloven, W. H. Schreurs, W. A. Draaisma, W. A. Enst et al.
Authors: D. G. Jayne
Authors: M. G. Sarr
Meta‐analysis of routine calcium/vitamin D3 supplementation versus serum calcium level‐based strategy to prevent postoperative hypocalcaemia after thyroidectomy.
Authors: A. Sanabria, A. Rojas, J. Arevalo
Authors: D. Nepogodiev, O. Omar, A. Bhangu
Randomized clinical trial
Multicentre randomized clinical trial of colonic J pouch or straight stapled colorectal reconstruction after low anterior resection for rectal cancer.
Authors: S. Pucciarelli, P. Del Bianco, U. Pace, F. Bianco, A. Restivo, I. Maretto et al.
Meta‐analysis of the effect of extending the interval after long‐course chemoradiotherapy before surgery in locally advanced rectal cancer.
Authors: É. J. Ryan, D. P. O'Sullivan, M. E. Kelly, A. Z. Syed, P. C. Neary, P. R. O'Connell et al.
Randomized clinical trial
Randomized clinical trial of accelerated enhanced recovery after minimally invasive colorectal cancer surgery (RecoverMI trial).
Authors: B. K. Bednarski, T. P. Nickerson, Y. N. You, C. A. Messick, B. Speer, V. Gottumukkala et al.
Authors: T. O. Sillo, A. D. Beggs, D. G. Morton, G. Middleton