Randomized feasibility trial of replacing or discarding the nail plate after nail‐bed repair in children. BJS 2017; 104: 1634-1639.
Published: 17th October 2017
Authors: A. Greig, M. D. Gardiner, A. Sierakowski, C. J. Zweifel, R. M. Pinder, D. Furniss et al.
Nail‐bed injuries are the most common hand injury in children. Surgical dogma is to replace the nail plate after repairing the nail bed. Recent evidence suggests this might increase infection rates and returns to clinic. The aim of this feasibility trial was to inform the design and conduct of a definitive trial comparing replacing or discarding the nail plate after nail‐bed repair.
This study recruited participants from four hand units in the UK between April and July 2015. Participants were children under the age of 16 years with a nail‐bed injury requiring surgery. They were randomized to either having the nail plate replaced or discarded after nail‐bed repair. The follow‐up method was also allocated randomly (postal
During the recruitment phase, there were 156 potentially eligible children. Sixty were randomized in just over 3 months using remote web‐based allocation. By 2 weeks, there were two infections, both in children with replaced nail plates. The nail‐replaced group also experienced more complications. There was no evidence of a difference in return rates between postal and clinic follow‐up.
Recruitment was rapid and nail‐bed repair appeared to have low complication and infection rates in this pilot trial. The findings have led to revision of the definitive trial protocol, including the mode and timing of follow‐up, and modification of the Zook classification.Read more
You may also be interested in
Authors: J. Mayol, J. Dziakova
Authors: K.‐J. Lundström, H. Holmberg, A. Montgomery, P. Nordin
Notes: Higher chronic pain rate than expected.
Population‐based incidence rate of inpatient and outpatient surgical procedures in a high‐income country.
Authors: E. Omling, A. Jarnheimer, J. Rose, J. Björk, J. G. Meara, L. Hagander et al.
Notes: Higher than previously reported
Authors: H. T. Malik, J. Marti, A. Darzi, E. Mossialos
Notes: Considerable savings
All‐cause and cardiovascular mortality risk after surgery versus radioiodine treatment for hyperthyroidism.
Authors: P. Giesecke, V. Frykman, G. Wallin, S. Lönn, A. Discacciati, O. Törring et al.
Notes: Surgery preferable for men
Optimal extent of completion lymphadenectomy for patients with melanoma and a positive sentinel node in the groin.
Authors: D. Verver, M. F. Madu, C. M. C. Oude Ophuis, M. Faut, J. H. W. de Wilt, J. J. Bonenkamp et al.
Notes: Inguinal is enough
Authors: V. Wanjura, E. Szabo, J. Österberg, J. Ottosson, L. Enochsson, G. Sandblom et al.
Notes: Avoid unnecessary surgery
Authors: P. D. Losty
Revised Functional Capacity Index as a predictor of outcome following injury. BJS 2017; 104: 1874-1883.
Authors: C. S. Palmer, B. J. Gabbe, P. A. Cameron
Randomized clinical trial
Randomized clinical trial of immersive virtual reality tour of the operating theatre in children before anaesthesia. BJS 2017; 104: 1628-1633.
Authors: J.‐H. Ryu, S.‐J. Park, J.‐W. Park, J.‐W. Kim, H.‐J. Yoo, T.‐W. Kim et al.
Notes: Reduces anxiety
Randomized clinical trial
Randomized clinical trial of antibiotic therapy for uncomplicated appendicitis. BJS 2017; 104: 1785-1790.
Authors: H. C. Park, M. J. Kim, B. H. Lee
Notes: No better than placebo
Characteristics of different mesh types for abdominal wall repair in an experimental model of peritonitis. BJS 2017; 104: 1884-1893.
Authors: R. Kaufmann, A. P. Jairam, I. M. Mulder, Z. Wu, J. Verhelst, S. Vennix et al.
Notes: Variable characteristics